Restate and Refine

Previous Up Next

Best Guide to Canadian Legal Research
Copyright © 1995-2008 Catherine P. Best
Conditions and terms of use

 

signpost.gif (1065 bytes)Often you will need to restate the issues after your secondary source review. You will also be in a position to flesh out the issues, by adding sub-issues, and determining which issues are straightforward and which are problematic.

bulletInitially your statement of issues may be as broad as negligence, or breach of contract. Expand it as you go to determine the relevant sub-issues such as elements of the cause of action, applicable remedies, defences available, onus of proof, policy considerations, limitations issues, evidentiary issues, contractual or statutory interpretation.
bulletYou may find that your problem can be approached under various legal subject areas or causes of action. Depending on how you characterize the problem, there may be advantages or disadvantages in terms of what must be proved, the remedies available, and the limitation period imposed.

The next step is to refine your research strategy for the various issues you have identified.

bulletSome may be dealt with quickly using leading authorities and trite law.
bulletOthers will require careful analysis of conflicting case law.
bulletOthers may not have been judicially considered and may require a creative approach based on analogous legal doctrines and first principles.

This means you will require a different research strategy for each issue. Use a research checklist to help you develop your strategy.

 

Back to Canadian Legal Research Homepage
This page was last modified  March 27, 2008
Copyright © 1995-2008 Catherine P. Best
Conditions and terms of use